And yeah, underneath everything I do, uh, lies, um, a curiosity in how cities work and function. Stop
Requested. This is Stop Requested. by ETA. I’m Christian. And I’m Levi. These are real conversations with the innovators, operators, and advocates driving improvements in public transportation.
Today, we’re joined by Yuval Fogelson, founder of YF City Urbanism, and associate at MoveMe, a. Canadian shared mobility consultancy. Yuval is an. urban designer and planner whose work explores how cities can rethink public spaces and make transportation. networks more connected and accessible.
We’ discuss tactical urbanism, how small changes to streets can lead to lasting improvements. We also explore curbside management and how physical design and technology can work together to make cities easier to navigate. Here’s our conversation with Yuval Fogelson.
Welcome back to Stop Requested. We’re here for another great episode, and today we’re joined, uh, by a, a very interesting individual that i- is bringing a lot of cool ideas related to transit planning and urbanism.
This is Mr. Yuval Fogelson, and he is the founder of YF City Urbanism, and also he is a specialist at MoveMe, Shared Mobility Consulting.
Uh, Yuval, how you doing today? I’m doing great. Thanks for having me. Thank you for joining us. And, and, you know, we were speaking just before we got started and, and you were sharing. I’m also another transit nerd. I, I have passion about transit and communities.
So this is gonna be a great conversation. But how about you introduce yourself to our listeners, let ’em know who you are, and a little bit about YF City Urbanism.
Sure. So I’m a urban designer. I’m also a urban and transportation planner, an educator, and also an artist. I currently run my own practice, YF City Urbanism, and I’m also, as you mentioned, a specialist at MoveMe Shared Mobility Consulting, uh, based here in Vancouver,
BC. And I also teach a course at the urban design program at the university here,
UBC. And yeah, YF City Urbanism looks at uniting, uh, all these different elements, uh, from urban design to mobility, you know, the inf- the public infrastructure, public space. It looks a lot at public space transformations, and I, I deal with this arc of change from temporary to permanent changes. Wow, that, that sounds very interesting. And, and, and those are a lot of titles that you keep yourself pretty busy.
Both, uh, the academia, the practice, and I’m interested to learn more what type of art you focus on. But that, that’s very interesting background.
Um, you know, I wanna learn more about your, your work. You, you just mentioned it spans, you know, tactical urbanism, a lot of these mobility hubs, you know, curb management, public spaces. What connects those areas for you?
W- w- why is it so important all… to combine all those things together? Yeah. Well, before I answer that, just on the art, I, I paint maps. I paint imaginary maps and things, things related to the kind of conceptual maps, but also, like, different topographies and also urban photography.
And it does relate to the, you know, urban design and, uh, city view that I have.
So what connects everything? Yeah, it is a wide range, and I like– I’m kind of a systems thinker and, you know, I think what connects it is it ranges from, from the very small scale, the hyperlocal scale of one curb space, all the way to a whole network. But I like to see that connection between the, how the hyperlocal is part of a wider network, which is m- often more done on the regional scale.
And yeah, like, the way it connects to mobility hubs is that if you connect a set of curbside, if you reallocate these i- in a consistent manner all across the city, you can create a network of, a network across the city, and not just look at the one side on its own. So that’s– But looking at one side on its own with the urban design lens, the public space design lens, is also very much needed for it to work and function well. And then the, the change aspect, that’s where the tactical urbanism comes in, which is, uh, very tied to the changing public space and especially the right of way. Like, mostly tactical urbanism is used- Right …
not to take a, a public park and put an activity there. Often that is also used and might be called placemaking. But tactical urbanism is very much used to reallocate, uh, space in the right of way that is dedicated for cars, for other uses. So that’s how tactical br- uh, tactical urbanism is really the, the kind of the, the engine to make it work. And yeah, underneath everything I do, uh, lies, um, a curiosity in how cities work and function, but also how they change over time.
Hmm. That, that’s very interesting and, and, you know, the… This is new for me. Uh, for some of our listeners, they, they might be familiar with tactical urbanism, but I have to be honest that this is new for me. Uh, and, you know, thank you for educating us o- on this. So the way that, that I understand it, a- and you mentioned networks, I think that that’s sort of piece that is very important because a lot of the times when we do development or, like, there’s opportunities to make a change is, like, in one place. But then, uh, uh, you have to create that consistency throughout all the different places within a city to create that network, right? Like, if you make-
Mm-hmm … one area, you know, where, where you have that right of way, where there’s, there’s a space for all, right? Like, you know, maybe there’s, there’s protected bicycle lanes, you know, a space for pedestrians and a space for, like, all, all the different mobility options. But then all, all these other places throughout the city, they’re car, car-centric, then you don’t have a strong network, right? Like, that’s not gonna help people utilize, you know, all the different spaces in the city in a way that is conducive for shared mobility or, or, you know, more mobility options.
So, uh, uh, but the tactical urbanism is, is make those… Like, the, the tactical piece is making those small, uh, improvements as you go along.
Like, uh, uh, could you explain that, break it down for me a little bit more? Yeah. Well, first of all, about the network, like an urban designer sees a lot of the city in terms of urban typologies and categorizing, uh, different land use or different locations into typologies.
And so while places are unique, might be have a unique character, as a typologies, they keep repeating themselves. You know, there’s different types of streets and different types of public spaces, different types of situations, so similar solutions have been tried and tested in different locations, and they can be repeated.
And in terms of tactical urbanism, and I’m sure we’ll talk more about it in, later in the interview, but it’s, it’s really a method of starting, starting small.
You can see it may be as the minimum viable product of urbanism. Mm. So if, like, you know, the entrepreneurs, uh, uh, like in the call or in the room will be kind of familiar with this concept of testing something in its most rudimentary crude form just to see if it has traction or if it works. So you’re already reconfiguring a space, taking over, reallocating space with light weight- with light and cheap material like paint and, you know, planters and bollards, things like that, that can be removable.
And then you can go out through different, uh, loops, through different feedback loops of testing and changing and, you know, getting and seeing how it works, and then making it more permanent before committing to a, a, a permanent solution, which is a lot, in orders of magnitude, uh, more expensive and complex to do. Now, now I understand. Thank you for, for clarifying it. I think I’ve seen that in communities where they have that street parking, and then they convert, like, temporarily the street parking into, like, space for- Curbside … people to dine and to do other activities. And, and I’ve seen in some places they make that permanently. Like, it started kind of like you, you could do it in a way that you could take it away and get the parking back, but then they saw the benefit, and then in some places they said, “Yeah, no more street parking.
We’re just gonna, you know, just use the space differently.” So that, that’s the part of the MVP of, of trying it. Mm-hmm. So that, that’s very interesting. And so how can cities test changes around transit stops, corridors, public space before making them permanent?
Like, how can this concept of, like, tactical urbanism be applied more around these transit stops? Right. So in terms of changing space, I think there’s two different type of, uh, you know, right of way spaces. There’s the stationary and there’s the space for moving. So s- stationary spaces like car parking, you can change it one curb space at a time. So you could do a curbside patio next to a restaurant, or you could do, um, an exte- a curbside extension at intersections to make it safer.
But in terms of moving, it’s the whole curb lane for which you can then trans- uh, you know, transform into a bike lane or a two-directional bike lane or into a bus lane.
But those, the problem with those ones are they have to be continuous. So if you just do a small segment, it’s again, it’s the question of the network. It has to feed into a network. So I think with regards to transit, the localized interventions could be around bus stops, for example. Now, at least here in Vancouver, they’re testing a lot of, you know, often on the parking lane of the curb, the bus would go in and pick up people, and then has to merge back into traffic. So now they’re extending a lot of places the curbside to, to move the bus stop, which gives people more room to wait, especially on crowded stops.
And then the bus, while it does stop the traffic behind it, once people get on, it goes, it flows. So it does reduce speed. Uh,
I mean, it does reduce the, the time between stops, and it does increase the speed of transit. So those are localized change.
But if you can get a whole lane and change it into a bi-directional bi- cycle way- Then in that case, you will be, you know, losing a whole, a lot of parking, and then that, that’s where things become more, more contentious. Hmm.
I see. So, so what separates a pilot that leads to lasting change from one that disappears? Like, what’s a good pilot?
Yeah. So I think there’s no real clear formula for this. And, you know, some projects wouldn’t ha- wouldn’t have happened without the pilot, but some projects, they would have happened anyway under a capital budget or under… Uh, when I say wouldn’t have happened, I meant the per- I mean, like, the permanent kind of phase. And a, a pilot that leads to, let’s say, nothing, it’s not necessarily a failure.
It could be that there wasn’t enough ambition, or it could also be a question of the design that wasn’t ideal or, uh, details were left out of or not to, to work properly.
And it could also be that some pilots are, are good just for one season. Like, maybe they’re more just for, for summer, like street closures and not for other parts of the year. But what interests me is really the elements that get tested in the temporary phases, how they then appear in the permanent design. So for me, a successful pilot is if anything in the pilot that was put there in, in order to test and in order to respond to, like, what the community are asking for and the public engagement in some wa- in some shape or form ends up embedded in, you know, how the place is configured or how it’s programmed later.
And I wanted to add also two things. One is this idea of nudging. So sometimes, uh, pilots happen when there isn’t a clear, uh, final–
Th- there’s uncertainty on the final outcome or the goal. So you can, um, start shifting a behavior and a nudging towards change that then it inevitably tilts it towards happening, whereas you might not have, uh, you know, might not see that in the beginning.
But there does need to be a vision. So there doesn’t need to be necessarily a clear defined end state, but there needs to be a vision of what we wanna work towards so that the earlier stages could, could work towards that. But the path to it is not always clear. So that’s, I think, where the, the experimentation, uh, works really well.
And then the last thing I wanted to mention also this idea of the, of being able to, to undo different changes because of the, the flexibility in the way that the, in the way that it’s designed, say, with paint and, and kind of removable or movable materials, means that you can undo or change the configuration.
So there’s, there’s one example that I lived in, in São Paulo in Brazil, and I always show this in, in kind of one of the lectures. There’s, there’s a cycleway that they painted on one side of the street right next to different restaurants, and they had this valet service, and, uh, they were complaining that, you know, the bike, the, the s- the new cycleway is in front of the restaurants.
And within a few months, they moved the cycleway to the other side of the street just by repainting it, and that’s a solution that can only be done with tactical urbanism methodology because you’re not putting in permanent infrastructure that is not undoable.
So the testing is sometimes very valuable, and when you put things– When things are real, uh, they’re, they’re real and functioning, that’s where the, it has to adapt to the, the way people actually use it.
So you’ve all– You, you said that you lived in São Paulo and y- you know, just wanna dig into your background a, a little bit more.
So could you share with us how you got started in, you know, this, this urbanism, urban design, you know, transit design space? I’m really curious to, to find out how you got to where you are now. Yeah. So, well,
I’ve lived all over the world in five continents, really. I’ll, you know… I, I started this as a kid. I was drawing maps of cities, so this map drawing was already a hobby of mine. And naturally, I ended up in architecture school but focusing on urban design, and I studied urban design and worked in master planning and public space.
Uh, you know, I lived in different countries: the Netherlands, Australia, Korea, Israel, and Brazil before, before moving to Canada.
And in, in São Paulo, I… Well, I also worked as an urban designer in an architecture firm, like designing new neighborhoods and, you know, greenfield sites or even a redev- ro- huge redevelopments, airports, things like that. But also, that’s where I started, co-founded URB-E, Urban Ideas, which we looked– we did a lot of tactical urbanism interventions. And also,
I was, I was leading this, uh, a virtual project called the Before and After Project, which, uh, basically collected images of public spaces around the world that transformed and showed how they transformed from before, after, with a focus on, you know, prioritization
Of pedestrian and active transportation. And then I, when I moved to Canada, I kind of started again. I did a research at UBC, which was, the research was focused on the future of curb space design and the transitioning into new mobility.
And that’s where the, where I could, uh, both integrate this, the idea of mobility hubs and the transportation side really came in. But also
I could use, uh, tactical urbanism as a method to show how to change this in phases. And top of the physical change, I looked at the virtual change. So because of the digi- the, the new, the newness of new mobility, and especially the curb space environment, is the digitization of curbside. And that’s where the virtual and physical, kind of matching the virtual and the physical came in. So that led me to work in consulting on curbside digitization and doing parking studies and mobility hub studies.
And now I have my, my own consulting, teaching, and I’m also writing about how cities change over time. That’s a really fascinating background, and you can see, uh, elements of kind of each building upon one another fr- from that story. Like, I was following along and I saw y- there’s, like, a little nugget there, and then you kind of carried that forward and then, you know, just kept moving this idea as time progressed. Y- you mentioned there at the end that you’re, you’re also doing some writing about cities.
Y- you know, what are you writing about these days? Is there something that’s piquing your interest that you’re, you’re just really enamored by? Yeah. Well, my main topic that I write about in general is urban transformations, and everything kind of sits under it.
One, one strand is this idea of time in the city. So I wrote, like, series about, or a city, a series titled Time in the City. It’s a f- a five-part series, and it looks at time in different ways. So time as a unit, so how does the city change in minutes, in hours, in, in weeks, say the weekend versus the week, or night versus day, like a night market, uh, that appears.
And then this idea of seasons. Some things the city changes physically over the seasons. And then years, and over a few years, you can now already have actual changes in public space or buildings get built. And decades, where you can actually see processes like gentrification or urban decay happening. Or generations, where you actually see, um, in the beginning of a, a generation… Or, or let’s say, like, when, uh, for example, when highways were planned all across North America going through cities at the time, they couldn’t imagine that in one or two generations, the same highways, s- some of them might get removed and replaced.
So, you know, this idea of time is something that really interests me. And then there is, like, the city and its past, the city and its future, the city and the present. So I, I really like this idea of time.
And another strand is typologies, like looking at things like skylines, overpass removal, underpass, stream, like river recovery, showing different urban change, different transformation by kind of by, by different typologies.
And there’s another article that I wrote recently which I think might be interesting also for this audience.
I was, I was trying to visualize what people often call, like, gentrification, but kind of the caricature version of it. And I looked into two locations in, in New York City. One is, like, Bleecker
Street, for example, where I looked at just taking Street View and looking at two shop fronts next to each other, and one of them was a record store, the other was a produce store, a produce shop. And then the record store became Starbucks, and then that closed, and it became something else, and the produce store became a gallery, and then it became something else. And there, and then I just followed the story, trying to, you know, look just through the images, reading the story. And so that’s like, that, those are the type of things that I like to… It’s kind of like a urban detective. I love, uh, spending, uh- … hours on Street View and, you know, going down rabbit holes. So I try and kind of bring that and make stories out of it. Today’s episode is brought to you by
ETA. Transit agencies rely on dozens of systems to keep service moving, but the information inside them often remains disconnected. Transit OS connects operational technology, enterprise software, and public data so agencies can bring more of their information into a shared operational context.
Transit GPT gives transit professionals a practical way to use that connected data, asking questions in plain language and getting answers grounded in agency information. Together, they help agencies see service clearly, respond faster, and deliver more reliable trips for riders. Learn more at etatransit.com.
Th- th- that sounds very interesting. A- and, you know, I’m just- Curious on, on that you just described. I wanna know everything you’ve learned throughout the years of investigating and, and looking at that timeline, right?
Because then you see as things are changing, what’s working and what’s the impact. In some places they’ve made some decisions and made ce- certain determinations, you know, if that made that area or that part of the community better and described better in, in the way that is making lives better for the people that are, are enjoying that space, or it has actually made the place worse, where, you know, like the, the conditions of the place, the, the use of the space is just not what it used to be. So, but I don’t wanna try to get that far into that, but I, I’m curious.
Mm-hmm. I just, I can empathize with, you know, the timeline, just watching time and see how things change, and then how those decisions on, on how the spaces change determines, uh, you know, h- how the space is used. So very interesting. But I, I wanna connect this as a public transit nerd to transit.
So, you know, y- you work on mobility hubs. A- and, and, you know, these, of course, they work around transit. Uh, in your opinion, in, in, with all that research you’ve done, what makes a, a mobility hub actually useful?
Yeah. So I think the main role of a, of a mobility hub is actually to expand the, the coverage or the reach or the radius from w- areas which are already served by good transit, and expanding it so more people can have reliable and convenient car-light living. I know it sounds maybe, like, impossible for a lot of the, um, population, but I think that’s the main role of, uh, y- like that’s a main role of the mobility hub. And it’s our, it’s all, it’s usually around transit re- uh, you know, it’s re- usually part of the, the transit network, so it’s expanding the reach of people that could use transit, so it’s kind of laid on top of the network. So again, for me it’s about, really about the network rather than one hub. So one hub could be designed amazing, but if it’s not part of a network, then
I think it’s, uh, it’s less useful, as you asked. And, and in the individual side itself, so a hub to be actually functioning well, it’s all the, let’s call it the in between, so the transition between one mode to another, the transition, the, the trip chaining. Like what happens in that in between.
You know, a lot of people like to use the word, like, seamless connection or, uh, things like that. But it’s more, it’s more about the, the flowing, uh, like dedicating and prioritizing the flow between the, the modes. Give it like a generous design, low barrier, very visually connected, and good way finding.
And, you know, an example for that would be when you’re just stepping outside of a, a train station or a metro station, can y- if you can see directly the bike share right somewhere in your field of vision, or, or if you can’t, if there’s way finding directing you to it. So often that doesn’t exist, and then you have to rely on virtual way finding, look on the app, try and figure it out. So just, uh, removing friction is what, you know, a useful and good mobility hub would be in my eyes. And, and that’s- And then just- Oh, go ahead. Yeah, just o- one more thing, and it’s also about the, the where you locate all these other mobility options. So it’s about the co-location of the shared bike, where the bus stops, where there’s amenities.
Th- like the, a really, a thinking of, of the thinking of where to locate things, and if things are already existing, have good way- way finding around different obstacles so that flow, y- you know, that flow ri- like as part of feels in- as intuitive as possible. And, and, you know, I really like what you just said, uh, in terms of the, the ease of connectivity and, and transition in between modes and options for people that are traversing, you know, the, the, the area.
You know, one, one of the transit systems I say that I’m a big fan of is Cap Metro in Austin, and it’s because you see a lot of these transit planning practices or, or best practices in place, right? Something you just alluded to is when you get off light rail station, like right there, there’s electric bikes.
And not only that, is that the, the app they have for selling the tickets allows you to buy access to the bus, the rail, and the electric bikes.
So it is, is almost like set up for you to take advantage of all those options as you go through your journey, right? Every journey starts as a pedestrian.
And, and what are we doing to make sure that as you go through your journey, you are able to easily navigate in between the different mobility options, including walking, right? Like get, to get from one place to another one, a lot of the times walking is, is a great way to go around your, your travel needs, right? You might not need to use any other option. Mm-hmm. But like a- any other best practices or, or what do you recommend cities in how they should think about this first/last mile connections to enhance their, their networks? Yeah. Well, I really like the kind of the first and last mile approach.
And often you can think it might happen in two different municipalities or in two… Even if it’s in the same jurisdiction, it might be two completely different land uses and different designs. Like on one end it could be your
You’re getting off the station and around you, you’re surrounded by strip malls, highways, and no bike lanes, and the other side, the other end of the trip could be completely walkable.
So I think the important thing is to think of both the beginning and the end of the trip so that way– so you experience it as one, you know, you experience it as one journey, and you can’t have such a drastically different, uh, experience in one end to the other, right?
So equalizing those experiences, and by that it doesn’t mean making the, the more walkable side less, but the other way around. So making the journey, uh, yeah, more that it ex- you experience it as one, uh, journey.
And, and that I think is, uh, where the, especially when it’s all these different municipalities, that’s I think where transit authorities, which are regional and often cover a metro area and multiple, uh, jurisdictions, they’re better positioned to, to kind of even out on both ends, right? So I think their respon- I think transit has a lot of responsibility for the adjacent, all the transit supportive modes and infrastructure that happens in that first and last mile. So the active transportation infrastructure leading to the, the, where, where there’s frequent transit, that’s, that’s the area where the mobi- So like imagine the mobility hub there is not only the station is the mobility hub, but within that last first mile, there are many small mini hubs where you can take these different modes and take the, uh, take your first leg of the trip to there, or maybe even take the full trip.
Yeah, that’s where I’d say it is. Yuval, you mentioned earlier your interest in, you know, curbside management.
I’m curious, why is the curbside being talked about so much now? It seems like in the last, I don’t know, five, 10 years, and you, you have, you have a lot of conversation about it.
Uh, why is it so important now compared to y- you know, 20 years ago? Yeah. Well, I’ve also worked in one of the curbside digitization companies, Curb IQ, and
I just, that was from my interest in my research. And what, what has changed is that it’s just become a more contested space.
More uses are competing for the same space. In the last, you know, decade or two, there’s been a big explosion in micro mobility and this idea of the curbside patio. Like before COVID, it was mostly parklets, but through COVID that w- that was like the lowest hanging fruit area that was easily enough to change with all the curbside patios and e- eateries and also giving space, uh, for people to, well, more space for people so they could have the distance.
Uh, so, so COVID was a big part of it and all the different micro mobility, but also all the delivery and, uh, you know, everyone is all the delivery, food delivery and all the, you know, e-commerce, all of that, they all, they’re all competing for that contested space, which c- before was mostly like seen as just a space for cars to park and then often also free or with less, not so much restrictions.
Yeah, and I think the contest that’s the, like the, the legacy uses, so mostly car parking need to now make room for new ones.
And plus there’s new ways of regulating and monetizing, and that’s kind of what creates a change.
So I think I mentioned like when we were talking before, so a lot of what, you know, curbside managers or parking, uh, managers or in as transport planners, what they need to do is basically change management. So they need to help the city diversify its curb. They need to change regulations, and they need on the one hand try and, you know, ex- prove to their council with hard numbers that are given by studies and engineers of how this can happen.
But then on to their, to the residents and to the, the, the shop owners, the retail, they, that, for example, for them, they can’t justify it with numbers. It’s more about, you know, managing, uh, people’s anxieties and feelings. So in that sense, that’s where the digitization of the curbside can be very handy.
So you can actually have numbers and measure curbside occupancy and parking usage and, you know, how much of the time is the curb, is it occupied? You know, if it’s consistently more than 80%, then it’s, it’s time to price it. You know, all the, the SHPO, the, the SHPO methodology.
So Yuval, uh, you, you know, I wanna talk a little bit more about the digital, uh, piece of the equation here. So h- how should cities think about the physical infrastructure and digital mobility systems together?
Yeah. I think it’s the ph- there’s the physical infrastructure of the city, and it’s, it’s setting the limitations of physical space and what ha- what is possible.
And within it, people, uh, can occupy space, whether for movement or stationary, but also in movement is like what route is taken.
Uh, and all that is now largely being, uh, supported by, you know, GPS and kind of routing.
But what happens is, is that the decisions that are made often now happen in the virtual rather than the physical. So they happen, like where you’re going and what you- route you’re gonna take is gonna happen in the beginning of the trip, following what the, the, you know, the app suggests.
And with that insertion of the digitization of the, the end location, if the end of the journey is in a parking, uh, a parking, um, garage which is being, you know, monitored or a curbside which is being monitored, then also the end of the route could be more precise to direct you to where, you know, things are available.
You know, there- therefore, you can eliminate circling the block. Things like that are a lot of the ideas behind this, and I think the, the m- one of the big aspects is real-time information, right?
So. Right. So real-time decisions don’t… Those decisions aren’t something that go up to some higher level to make deci- like policy decisions, right?
They’re, they’re decisions that just adapting supply and demand in the, in the existing system. So
I think by making the, the existing system more flexible, and things that I’ve been really interested in is like the digital curb, the flexible curb, the dynamic curb.
Has, has different names, but you could have d- you could set aside some, some, a small percentage of the curbside to be either for uses that a- already need to re- uh, already are using digital messa- methods like shared mobility, ride hail or car share ride hail or micro- shared micro mobility.
All these uses are only enabled digitally, and you cannot finish a ride if you’re not in the right geofence zone.
Or al- also like, uh, parking, uh, digital parking is very common, but it’s, it’s never really 100% enforced.
But you could do a combination of some of these, you know, flexible, flexible curb space that is designated for these uses, and then you could, um, manage the, how much you give each one according to real-time demand. Like, that is all possible, and that’s where I come into this idea of automation. So if you think about it, digitization is the first step towards automation.
Uh. So once, uh, we have everything digitized, now it can be automated, and I think that’s really where, at least at the time when I was working, uh, at Curb IQ for, uh, the focus was on creating a digital inventory of the supply.
Although there were some interesting projects with demand as well, meaning that there mu- there was some way of measuring real-time activity, whether through sensors or cameras or through parking data from the parking apps by, just by payment data.
So there was some way of combining also real time. But essentially, you know, you’d have to have sensors and cameras everywhere if you really wanna have a full system. But doesn’t need to be a, a kind of a, a full closed system.
But the more, the more the system is digitized, it becomes a closed system, which is enough that y- that the behavioral is predictable enough, and when behavior is predicted, it, it’s easier to automate it. So like think about an airport as a closed system- Right … in a way.
So it’s, it’s, it’s a lot more scheduled and automated. Even when things change schedule, everything kind of moves around, and in the city, we, we don’t have that. Now,
I’m not basically advocating for this, but this is what is possible, right? This is what is possible to- Right. Yeah. And, and, and that’s the challenge with public transit and ever-changing environment, right? Like, a, a lot of these in the ecosystem, a lot of these things you have no control of, or agencies don’t have the control of.
So all these things are, are always changing. And, you know, I li- I really liked, uh, how you explained the digital aspect of mobility because, you know, a lot of the times I feel for agencies could be a little bit more frustrating and limiting the physical space, like the infrastructure, you know, the owner of the right of way, the physical space. But like have they really explore all the improvements that can be done through technology on the digital space and how it can support making a better experience for the riders? And one of the things that you mentioned, and I think you, you, you were referring to real-time data for a lot of purposes, for the agencies and the planners and the people doing the analysis.
But, you know, I would imagine, and I think you were explaining that as well, when people are googling, you know, how to get from point A to point B, and then they get some options, uh, presented to them, that there’s a lot of opportunity there for public transit agencies to make some improvement and, and, you know, just drive some better mobility for those riders.
A- an- anything else you wanna add in that real time information that, that maybe is not, agencies are, are not considering it, you know- When, when they’re looking at how to improve their transit systems.
I think, I mean, this is largely done, but just by knowing when the next bus is and if it’s delayed or not, it just, it’s re- it’s removing that uncertainty from your trip, and it’s creating…
It’s, so I think like the psychological aspect of the trip, of going to a bus stop and not knowing if the bus already passed, if you just missed it or not, or knowing that, oh, where’s the bus? Oh, it says it’s now late.
So it calms you down. So those are even, uh, in a way, they make the trip the, the more that you can reduce uncertainty in the trip, the more likely that you will be, you know, taking that trip again, right? But also at the same time, if the bus is every single time, uh, late, then, then even, even the real-time information is not gonna, it still won’t be enough to, for you to maybe switch to another mode. So I think it helps in the, it helps in the planning and in the way we make our trips. But the other important thing is that during the trip, it’s not only a start of trip, it’s like during the trip you can make different decisions at any time, you know, to change where you’re going or how you’re going.
And, you know, there is, I, I think, I think for the aspect of the whole loading and unloading and use and, and, uh, short use of curb space, real-time information could be very useful because, because, uh, you know, a place could technically be often, often very busy and full, but you need to know it right for that minute how it is.
And so, yeah, real-time information, the more we have the, uh, kind of, it, uh, especially for ev- a lot of things that are dependent on, like, time and, uh, and efficiency.
Hmm. Well, yeah, that, that, that’s a great, good answer. And, and I think that agencies could capitalize more on, on making that information more prominent and accessible. for people when they’re riding the system.
Like you said, if, if you manage that expectation, it, it’s just a better customer experience, more likeliness for people to take this, these trips again. Yuval, this has been a great conversation. We’re starting to wind down, uh, towards the closing of our episode today, and we have two recurring segments that we do during our stop request conversation, and one is the rapid fire, where I’m gonna ask some short questions, quick, short answers.
Are you ready for it? Sure. Go. Favorite transit system. So I’d say Seoul. I lived there, and you could really get from any point to any point, and it was so ubiquitous that every time you were gonna meet someone, you’d just ask, you’d just say, “Oh, meet me at station such at exit number,” or something. And it’s like the default way, you know, people meet there.
So I think that’s, it’s, it’s so ubiquitous that that’s why I think it’s my favorite. Wow, that’s, that’s really interesting, you know, how people would organize their lives and everything around transit. Most overrated mobility trend. Well, that one is, I mean, I think AVs, probably a lot of people have been saying this, but I think in terms of the disruption, I, I know I, I looked into this, uh, maybe a decade ago or more, or less, but there was this hope that AV, that the disruption would be in the, to reduce car own- the car ownership model, and
I don’t, I think that we’re far from it at this point. Hmm. One thing cities get wrong about first and last mile access. I think, uh, what, I think the, it’s more the, they missing the last mile.
So maybe they’re looking at the first 300 feet, like the immediate en- environment of the station. Often that’s what the transit agency can control, but not the rest of the mile, not the rest of the first or last mile.
So I think that’s really important. Yeah. Most undervalued piece of a street space. Well, we already talked about it, but I think the curb space, the curb wins it. I think it’s, it’s the most undervalued because it’s actually ubiquitous. It’s everywhere. Right. And so th- you could do the most with it, but it, it doesn’t feel like it’s something, you know? It’s just a space and it’s, you can, if you un- you can unlock it as a network, as I said, in so many different places.
Hmm. A city doing mobility and public space particularly well. Well, there’s many cities I’ve been to around the world, but last week I was at an active transportation summit in Victoria, BC, and
I, I, like it’s, it’s kind of a small city, but it has things like the large cities have. But what I found interesting was I was just walking to the venue in, in the morning and just along all this really great bike infrastructure and just people were passing by on the cargo bikes, running errands. It didn’t feel unusual, right?
It just felt like the normal everyday life there, seeing multiple cargo bikes and I think for a North American city, that’s quite unique. So Yuval, uh, as Christian mentioned, we’re, we’re coming to the end here, and I have some takeaways that I was writing down as you were speaking and we were going through our conversation.
There’s a lot of, you know, really good gems that y- you had throughout You know, your explanations, and I took down quite a few. I’m going to try to keep it succinct, though.
You tell me if I got any of these wrong or if you would say them differently. The, the first one that sticks out to me was that you said unsuccessful pilots does not necessarily mean that it was a failure.
You know, you can, you can continue to learn and take that information back even to iterate and, and to improve, or that could go into the final design if it ends up being a permanent structure of some sort, per-permanent infrastructure.
You also said that y- you know, many times that the curb is, uh, overlooked, and that can also be a, a network in and of itself. Mobility hubs should extend the reach of existing transit.
It’s not just a destination, but it can be a… for you to pass through the system and continue on your journey. Um, reducing frictions where you can, you know, especially, you know, making those connections or the transfers in between, you know, different aspects of your system. Reducing that friction is gonna be very important to make the customer experience better. Uh, I, I like that you mentioned, uh, the co-location as well as connection, right? We often think of, like, oh, I can connect to go from here to there, but, you know, placement of, uh, of different destinations or different, uh, types of mobility in and around each other can help make a, a better experience, can improve mobility as well.
And then lastly, you know, your, your focus, it seems, is a lot on design or at least a lot of design thinking.
Yeah. Y- you know, so that technology shouldn’t be, shouldn’t be considered the only solution, right? Like, we, we have other tools in our toolbox to be able to build good cities. I’d say for the first one about the pilot, that methodology point of view, failing is not an issue, but from a, you know, the public perception or from communications point of view, then that can be an issue because, you know, people are often already see, like, experimentation as a risk.
And then if something doesn’t work, then it might end up kind of, you know, causing the, causing it to be completely canceled. But from a methodology point of view, a failure is still part of what it’s supposed to do.
And what was the last thing that you mentioned? I remember the last question there was something- Uh, about design. The last takeaway was about design. Oh, yeah.
Mm-hmm. Yeah, these things have to happen in tandem. Like, we’re looking at our phone, but we’re also looking in space and, you know, some things, uh, could be part… They’re, they’re, they have to work together, right? And if what you’re seeing on the phone and what you’re seeing in the physical space match, then that’s, uh, even better. Excellent. Well, I appreciate that. Thank you for correcting those, those mistakes there and just, uh, elucidating a little bit more. You know, this has been a, a really enlightening conversation.
I, I wanna make sure that, you know, folks are able to connect with you or, you know, learn more about you, your projects, your artwork. Uh, how can they do so,
Yuval? Yeah. Well, you could reach me on LinkedIn, just my name, and you can look at my website yfcity.city, or also my Movmi consulting at
Movmi, so that’s M-O-V-M-I.net. So those are the two websites. Perfect.
Uh, again, Yuval, this has been a wonderful conversation. Really appreciate you joining us, and, you know, the breadth of what you’re able to cover is really astounding. Very impressive. Enjoyed this conversation thoroughly, and I hope that our audience did as well. And to our audience, thank you so much for listening to Stop Requested this week. We’ll be back next Monday with another episode.